In ad and speech, McCain invokes Vietnam -- again and again

This was first posted on Campaign Diaries.

John McCain has long benefited from the conventional wisdom that he is uncumfortable invoking his years in Vietnam and as a POW on the campaign trail. But back in December, McCain's decision to air an ad in New Hampshire devoted to his experience as a POW suggested that Vietnam could play more central a role than McCain would like us to believe. (As a side note, it is really worth rereading the late December post I wrote at the time as it is a fascinating reminder of just how late McCain surged and just how chaotic the GOP race was just two weeks before Iowa.)

Now, McCain is at it again. His latest ad is a one-minute spot, the first part of which is devoted to celebrating the Arizona Senator's service in Vietnam. The ad starts with images of anti-war protests and of kissing (and I believe cross-dressing) hippies ("It was a time of uncertainty, hope and change. The "Summer Of Love.") and contrasts them with what McCain was doing at the same time: "Half a world away, another kind of love -- of country. John McCain: Shot down. Bayoneted. Tortured. Offered early release, he said, "No." He'd sworn an oath."

The take-home message: While leftist radicals were busy not serving their country and amusing themselves in degenerate festivals like Woodstock's, McCain was putting himself in harm's way to serve his country. (Note that Obama was only 6 when McCain's plane was shot down and 8 during Woodstock, so McCain cannot criticize him in this vein.) Just like the December ad, this spot uses footage of McCain as a POW:

The rest of this biographical ad praises the Senator's Senate service in what looks like an effort to build a brand. The ad ends simply with the words "McCain" and check the buzzwords that are used: "Maverick" is a prominent one and "reform" is repeated over and over again. McCain's message is that he is not beholden to his party and has no other allegiance than serving America: "He took on presidents, partisans and popular opinion. (...) John McCain doesn't always tell us what we 'hope' to hear." These are the themes McCain has been emphasizing for weeks and also the message that is contained in the RNC's contrast ad on energy: moderation and pragmatism.

Without naming him, the ad takes a shot at Obama ("Beautiful words cannot make our lives better") -- though keep in mind that the Clinton campaign attempted the very same type of attack in the Democratic primaries (remember the "sky will open, the light will come down" speech?). Clinton was not able to convince voters Obama was all talk and empty hope, so will McCain adapt those arguments to learn from Clinton's failure or does his campaign believe that McCain's life story is more compelling than Clinton's, making the talk v. action contrast more  successful?

And how will voters react to McCain's use of Vietnam? It certainly did not help John Kerry in 2004 and there are obvious reasons it could backfire on McCain. For one, it reminds voters of his age, especially when contrasted with a youthful Democratic candidate who prides himself for not being part of the Vietnam generation. In 2004, McCain said he was "sick and tired of re-fighting the Vietnam War" but it is Obama who is promising to move past the Vietnam era. And how much can McCain invoke Vietnam without giving the impression he is exploiting his service too opportunistically?

McCain's speech on immigration today had a long reference to McCain's POW days, suggesting that the candidate is really planning on using Vietnam any time he possibly can, even on issues that are entirely unrelated. After explaining why the country needs comprehensive immiration reform, McCain's speech includes this passage:

When I was in prison in Vietnam, I like other of my fellow POWs, was offered early release by my captors. Most of us refused because we were bound to our code of conduct, which said those who had been captured the earliest had to be released the soonest. My friend, Everett Alvarez, a brave American of Mexican descent, had been shot down years before I was, and had suffered for his country much more and much longer than I had. To leave him behind would have shamed us.

John Kerry ended up being hurt by his tendency to rely on Vietnam on the campaign trail. Will McCain?



Display:


tip jar! (2.00 / 3)


by LeftistAddiction on Tue Jul 08, 2008 at 01:29:04 PM EST

Re: In ad and speech, McCain invokes Vietnam -- ag (none / 0)

complete sham


McCain - a serial Opportunist, from marriage to policy positions
by TarHeel on Tue Jul 08, 2008 at 01:48:32 PM EST

Re: In ad and speech, McCain invokes Vietnam -- ag (none / 0)

Thats a great ad .


Educated in a small town Taught to fear Jesus in a small town Used to daydream in that small town Another born romantic that's me.
by lori on Tue Jul 08, 2008 at 01:51:09 PM EST

Re: In ad and speech, McCain invokes Vietnam (none / 0)

A noun and a verb and Vietnam.


by rfahey22 on Tue Jul 08, 2008 at 01:52:04 PM EST

It might work with independents and liberals.... (none / 0)

What is interesting is, for all their wailing and moaning about Patrotism and Military matters, it surely didn't help McCain against Bush in '00, when the Roveian wing of the party painted McCain as a manchurian madman.

They are fake stay at home Chickenhawks, just like their true leader Cheney.

What is ALSO interesting is, Liberals actually respond in stronger kind, becuase we DO honor sacrifice and devotion to country.

There was a TON of backlash to Wes Clarks going at McCain from the left, where as when Kerry was attacked, the right just piled on with glee.

Republics, they worship money and power.

All their "Flag and Country Worship" is a fake.


On Nov 4th, Barack Obama officially ends the Southern Strategy....
by WashStateBlue on Tue Jul 08, 2008 at 02:04:47 PM EST

It made more sense in '04 than now. (none / 0)

George W. Bush was of draft age and did not serve in Vietnam.  It was a good contrast, and although Kerry didn't win the election, I still think it earned him some votes (he did better with the military vote than Gore in '00).  Also, McCain has the misfortune of following a campaign that focussed on Vietnam.  I think you should dig for some more quotes -- McCain said even more pointed things about Kerry using his Vietnam service.

Anyway, I plan to ask my winger friends to condemn McCain for using his Vietnam service the way they did against Kerry.  For the record, I don't have a problem with candidates trumpeting their service to their country; I just resent McCain bashing Kerry for doing something that he is doing now.


by beachmom on Tue Jul 08, 2008 at 06:44:05 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.